Penn Revises Open Expression Guidelines to Expand Committee Oversight and Clarify Protest Rules
The University of Pennsylvania’s Committee on Open Expression has released a revised draft of its guidelines for campus speech, significantly altering the governance structure established in March. The new proposal reduces the Provost’s administrative authority, expands the committee’s oversight powers, and clarifies rules regarding spontaneous protests and online conduct following extensive community feedback.
The University of Pennsylvania’s Committee on Open Expression released a revised draft of the institution’s Guidelines on Open Expression on Tuesday, marking a significant shift in how campus speech and assembly will be governed. The proposal revisits key provisions from a March draft that had drawn substantial criticism, specifically addressing administrative authority, the regulation of spontaneous demonstrations, online speech boundaries, and protocols for identification checks.
The revised document incorporates feedback gathered during spring listening sessions and written submissions, as well as input from the Offices of the President and the Provost. According to the committee, these changes aim to "strike a careful balance between preserving robust internal disagreement and protecting the University’s academic environment from institutional censorship and undue external pressure" by embedding layered checks and balances into event facilitation.
A central feature of the revision is the restructuring of authority within the university administration. Compared to the initial March draft, which proposed expanding the role of the Provost, the new structure moves much of the operational authority away from that office. The provost’s expanded role had been a significant source of concern for previous committee members and others in the campus community.
The March draft had proposed a committee of 13 members named or approved by the provost. The revised draft returns to a composition of 17 voting members selected by their respective constituencies, consisting of eight faculty members, three staff members, and six students. This composition mirrors the structure prescribed by the university’s existing 1993 guidelines.
Furthermore, the new proposal identifies the Committee on Open Expression as a standing committee of the University Council and introduces a tri-chair structure comprising a past chair, a current chair, and a chair-elect. Committee members will select the chair-elect from among their faculty representatives. Currently, the committee operates as an independent body of the Council, whereas the March draft had proposed having it jointly report to the provost and the Faculty Senate tri-chairs.
The role of the executive director of open expression remains in the new proposal but with enhanced oversight mechanisms. The executive director would work within an independent Office of Open Expression under the provost, with "primary operational oversight from COE" (Committee on Open Expression). Committee members will constitute a voting majority of the search committee for this position. In the first draft, the executive director reported directly to the provost and provided a dotted-line report to the Faculty Senate tri-chairs, with the provost selecting the director in consultation with other bodies.
The proposal also addresses concerns regarding vague language that characterized the previous draft. Many community members had pointed to phrases such as "unreasonably disrupt" and "interfere unreasonably" as enabling "unbridled interpretive discretion." The new proposal features a dedicated section defining key terms, including "event," which is defined as "a planned undertaking for the purpose of expression." The lines containing the phrases "interfere unreasonably with the regular activities of others" and "unreasonably disrupting the normal activity that takes place within the University" have been deleted. The remaining standards for determining violations now frequently feature the words "negligently, recklessly, or intentionally."
Scheduling provisions have also been revised to address concerns about accommodating protests responding to unfolding events. The general scheduling section has removed the earlier requirement for a seven-business-day application for specified campus spaces, including Blanche P. Levy Park and Locust Walk. It now states that "spontaneous expressive activities may occur in any outdoor, publicly accessible campus space, provided they do not violate any guidelines or conflict with previously-registered events in the same space."
However, a separate provision retains seven business days as the definition of a timely request for speaker venues and related services. Scheduling procedures continue to vary by venue, and some events may still require security assessments. Currently, event scheduling is governed by temporary standards that call for all events to be registered at least 48 hours in advance, with those occurring in specific locations like Blanche P. Levy Park requiring registration two weeks beforehand.
The scope of online regulation was another major point of contention during the feedback period. The chairs of the Penn Association for Gender Equity had questioned whether the draft’s provisions could extend to personal accounts, writing that "this lack of clarity could mean that students’ personal social media could be subject to University discipline." The new draft removes a broad reference to "cyberspace" and specifies that the guidelines apply only to circumstances involving university premises, affiliated groups, university resources, or representations of university affiliation. The draft expressly excludes "teaching or research activities or clinical care," stating these are governed by policies specific to their respective domains.
Regarding identification checks, the proposal prescribes greater limits on when they can be made compared to the March draft. Campus Expression Facilitators can ask to see Penn IDs if repeated de-escalation attempts fail to resolve a potential violation. If the violation persists after the request, they can record identifying information, provided they first notify those involved. The proposal notes that obligations regarding ID requests from law enforcement officers, such as the Philadelphia Police and Penn Police, are governed by statutes.
The Campus Expression Facilitator program, previously known as the Open Expression Observer program, allows individuals referred for disciplinary action to appeal to the open expression committee’s tri-chairs, who can temporarily issue a stay of the referral pending review by a committee panel. The proposal separately permits facilitators or the executive director to contact the Division of Public Safety in extenuating circumstances, with such requests for assistance reported to the COE.
Other restrictions on blocked access, disruptive sound, and unauthorized temporary structures broadly remain, though details have changed. Temporary structures, including tents, still require authorization, although the revised draft omits the word "encampments." Projected images now require the executive director’s review and approval, with detailed written reasons required for submissions that are rejected. The new proposal clarifies that chalking is permitted on sidewalks and outdoor stairways only, in accordance with existing policies. Regarding sound, the most recent proposal specifically bans "continuous, recurring, or daily high-volume sound" when it "systematically degrades surrounding living, study, or research environments," replacing the rigid restrictions on time and location found in the old draft.
Once finalized, the revised guidelines will replace the currently in-effect 1993 rules, which have been clarified by interpretive guidelines over the years and partially replaced by temporary standards for demonstrations. Feedback for further revisions will be accepted through additional listening sessions scheduled in November, with written comments accepted until December 7.
J.Sayed--CdE